Your Guide to the Best Pizza in Montauk, NY

There is no shortage of pizza options in Montauk.  Sometimes I think there is actually too much pizza in Montauk. 

But lucky for you, pizza is one of my favorite food groups and I’m here to tell you where to find the best pizza in Montauk.  I have also taken it upon myself to eat at every single one of these places to refresh my memory and snap some photos of pizza – so you can take my word that I have eaten at all of the places listed below more than once. (some more than I am willing to admit)

There are sit down options, to go, pizzeria style and artisan style pizza options.  Keep reading to find out the best slice in Montauk and which is the best option for you.

Where to Find the Best Pizza in Montauk:

1. Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities

Best for: classic NY style pizzeria

My vote for best New York style pizzeria in Montauk.  Sausages Pizza & Pastabilities has it down! 

They have a classic plain, pepperoni, white, grandma, Sicilian and not to mention all their specialty slices like their amazing barbecue chicken pizza.  A lot of their speciality slices come with sesame seeds on the crust which is such a small detail but I love sesame seeds and maybe you do too.

Sausages has plenty of tables to sit down and dine in and they even offer Italian dinners if that is what you’re feeling. This is my pick for a quick lunch or pizza dinner.

2. Fierro’s

Best for: NY style take out

A long time favorite from East Hampton Village, Fierro’s Pizza has a new outpost in Montauk!

They are conveniently located in the same parking lot as Montauk Brewing Company and the town softball fields. Fierro’s offers classic NY style pizza take out. But they do have some picnic benches for outdoor seating too.

In addition to pizza you can also order sandwiches and full Italian dinners.

3. Alimentari Beach

Best for: thin crust pizza & Italian food

Alimentari Beach is located right in the center of town across the street from the gazebo and the green. They don’t offer pizza by the slice but they do offer personal (or shareable) size thin crust pizza.  Alimentari has a few different variations like burrata, pepperoni, tartufo, clam and veggie.

They also serve fantastic Italian dishes! I love eating any of their pasta dishes – you must try their meatballs.

You can order at a table inside the restaurant or request to sit at one of their tables outside in the center of town with an Aperol spritz or glass of wine and enjoy people watching. (There is live music Monday nights on The Green in July and August!)

4. Dive Bar Pizza

Formerly known as Best Pizza, Dive Bar Pizza relocated from the Napeague Stretch to Montauk Harbor and we’re so happy to have them here!

Dive Bar is a cool hangout right on the docks in Montauk Harbor. Not only is it a cool bar scene but their pizza is really good and different than everywhere else. Their crust is super thin and their slices big! My favorite is the white pizza.

5. Il Forno at Montauk Yacht Club

Best for: wood fired pizza, lake views & upscale seafood

Il Forno is located in the Montauk Yacht Club on Lake Montauk – so off the bat this is the only pizza in Montauk with water views! I love to come sit in the Il Forno cafe next to their outdoor pool or sit at the bar and order a drink and wood fired pizza. (bonus: the ceasar salad is SO GOOD!)

Must Read: the best waterfront dining in Montauk

6. Harvest on Fort Pond

Best for: pizza & family style dining

Harvest on Fort Pond is ALWAYS busy and it is always good. Although not a pizza place they do have really good pizza options on the menu in addition to their family style menu.

My favorite is the bacon jalapeño pizza which we sometimes order as an appetizer or order with a salad and have as dinner. Don’t sleep on the bacon jalapeño pizza and thank me in the comments 🙂

For more dining options read: Ultimate Montauk Travel Guide

7. Pizza Village

Best for: late night slice of pizza

Pizza Village has been around since before I can remember.  (We took a field trip here in kindergarten to make pizza!). However, the ownership has changed hands a few times over the years and this is actually my least favorite pizza in Montauk.  Although, some of my friends would argue differently so I am still including this on the list! 

Pizza Village is great though for a late night slice of pizza. Wether you’ve gotten into Montauk late or are out bar hopping and it’s 2am and you just left the Memory Motel – Pizza Village is there serving hot cheese pizza right out the window!

BONUS: Fini Pizza

Best for: really good pizza

Fini Pizza is just across the Napeague stretch in the town of Amagansett. They occupied the longtime Astro’s Pizza location on Main Street but let me tell you their pizza is GOOD. Like really good and worth driving 15 minutes to grab a fresh pie!